Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Republican Party Blues

Anyone who is a Republican should be very worried about their party. An unruly triumvirate - Rush Limbaugh, Michael Steele and Newt Gingrich - is highlighting a very uncomfortable discord within the Party. While the Republicans fight amongst themselves for direction after finally losing their absolute power with the election of Barack Obama, they have marginalized their core values of fiscal responsibility, moral rectitude and conservative values with complete buffoonery and braggadocio in a manner unbefitting a major political party. They have consigned themselves to attacking the President at every turn and injecting, once again, negative and divisive politics to the point where most Republicans in Congress refuse to cooperate and/or endorse any of the current economic stimulus plans that have been proposed.

Thomas Friedman sums this up well in his article published 3/10/09 in the New York Times,

"...the Republican Party behaves as if it would rather see the country fail than Barack Obama succeed. Rush Limbaugh, the de facto G.O.P. boss, said so explicitly, prompting John McCain to declare about President Obama to Politico: “I don’t want him to fail in his mission of restoring our economy.” The G.O.P. is actually debating whether it wants our president to fail. Rather than help the president make the hard calls, the G.O.P. has opted for cat calls. It would be as if on the morning after 9/11, Democrats said they wanted no part of any war against Al Qaeda — “George Bush, you’re on your own.”"

I just think back to President Bush's terms in office where he took advantage of the generous rule; we all stand together when the country is in crisis or at war. If anyone criticized President Bush or went against the grade, they were deemed unpatriotic and would have been soundly attacked and destroyed by the media. Remember what happened to General Shinseki when he went against the President and tried to say the right thing, that we needed more initial troops for the Iraq War? Anyone remember that the Democratic Party voted lockstep with Bush and the Republicans even after winning the majority in Congress in 2006?

Now, the Republican Party is sitting around complaining, being downright nasty during a period where we need intelligent dialogue and communication. We know things are bad, all you have to do is look around. We shouldn't be watching our Republican Congresspeople acting like idiots - being petty by angrily declining small portions of the stimulus funds for their home states while taking the bulk of the money and/or adding earmarks to the new Omnibus Spending bill signed today yet screaming that there are too many. I know they are richer than most of us so they don't feel the economic hit like us regular folks but is this the best we can do when we get together and vote for these people to represent us? People so seemingly out of touch with reality.

Everyone is scared. I don't see any economists jumping up and saying everything is going to be Okay in the near term. In fact, they are all on the same page concluding that the government and its entities have to put as much money as they can into the economy to save it. The only criticism I'm seeing is that the stimulus packages are too low. Meanwhile, the Republicans are saying we shouldn't spend at all and put the country into more debt. You know, if they had stuck to their tenet of fiscal responsibility during Bush, we might very well have had the money to save ourselves. Instead they followed Bush down the road, spending us into massive deb. Now they have dismissed Bush completely as if he was never a Republican at all. Amazing.

We are not economists, we have no clue how dire the situation is but we have to do something. Maybe the current proscriptions are not right, maybe they won't help, maybe the economy has to correct itself on its own, maybe billions of dollars might be wasted as money is thrown around to save us, maybe all of this stimulus will come to naught but whatever happens, we have to hope for the best. At the very least, in unity there is strength.

During the Depression, the one beacon of hope was the President. We need to be positive because we are facing deep distress; we have to face it together if we have any chance of getting out of it. Deliberately wishing that the President and by extension the Democrats fail so it can be harped on and used as a negative during Obama's reelection bid in 2012 is all that the Republicans are hoping for. And, they don't seem to care how they get there. How sad.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Getting Our "Acts" Together

I see the pundits on television, which I have curtailed sharply since the election cycle and subsequent inauguration, now shifting their attention to the economy. These one-time "political commentators" are now "economic experts" all jawboning about what we should do to weather the storm. I know as much as they do, which is not much. None of us our economists, we really do not know how far the fissure runs or how deep. The facts keep coming out piece-meal, without any company owning up to their true exposure, leaving us all to speculate and argue over the one plan that we have. It would be nice if there was dialogue about the several plans proposed but we only have one plan...for the government to shovel in as much cash as it can to keep us all afloat.

When the TARP plan was introduced, we hurried the process because it was needed ASAP to avert the failure of the US and by extension world financial systems. It passed with flaws. When the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA?) was similarly rushed and passed just a few weeks ago, it too passed with flaws. It seems that we have no time to get our Acts together, so to speak. Everything is a big rush to save us from pain and the expectations are too high.

Amongst ourselves, we talk of surviving this year and wondering about the next. What are we supposed to believe when the stock market rallies because the street got wind of an internal memo at Citigroup that said all will be well with the bank, it was profitable in January and February. Well if the Government owns 36% of the bank by way of a $30,000,000,000+ capital injection that the bank has received from taxpayers, I'd say things were pretty good too though it baffles the mind that you can call yourself profitable when you've just been bailed out. But would I believe CEO Vikram Pandit? No. This is something every CEO says to boost morale. You have to believe that things will get better even if they don't. And besides, Bernanke said again today that certain banks, like Citigroup, will not be allowed to fail. There is no other plan.

Monday, March 9, 2009

Depression-Era Solutions May Not Save Consumer Economy

There has been a lot of discussion comparing today's economic climate with that of the Depression. The more I listen to the discussion is the more I conclude that other than having similar types of dreadful economic statistics, we are in a completely new economic situation for which history cannot give us any pointers.

During the depression, America was still an industrial society producing goods and services. This helped to position the U.S. for dependable growth through World War II and beyond. American companies created goods and services right here at home and much of the actions taken by FDR and the government to address the economic woes were executed in a protected national economy that was not intertwined completely with the rest of the world as it is now. The last vestiges of American companies and American products are also under siege; there is a lot more competition in the world and right now it appears that American goods and services are not holding up as well.

For most of the 1900s, America was a producer of goods and services exported all over the world. Now, America imports more goods that it exports and has moved away from a producer society to a consumer society; somewhere along the line America stopped producing goods and started producing consumers. Clearly, this has not been a good development. Now, consumer spending is at 70% of GDP; the consumer has to start spending again for the economy to stabilize and in order for the economy to grow, consumers have to spend even more to keep the cogs turning.

Unfortunately, as the downturn continues to go from bad to worse, the consumer is now forced to live within their means and/or saving cash as they vie for survival. Who knew that saving would be referred to as bad for the economy? When I was growing up, saving was an integral part of fiscal responsibility and lauded as a noble goal for all who were serious about moving up in the world. Now, saving is a dirty word. All who are saving are not spending and without spending, we have no economy.

The solutions that are currently being implemented are for this purpose, to get more money into the pocket of the consumer and get more money flowing for the consumer to borrow and spend. In a $14 trillion dollar economy, consumer spending accounts for nearly $10 trillion if the numbers are right. What will replace the decline in consumer spending and lift the economy?

I'm not sure Depression-era solutions will hold up in this new global economy.We need a new set of industries if we are to have firm footing again. Throwing trillions of dollars at the financial institutions and a few select industries may help to get us back to where we were. However, I don't think America should be looking backwards to restore an economy that I believe is breathing its last gasps. Consumer spending should not be the keys to America's future success.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Lions and Tigers and Bears, Oh My

Can it be that Citigroup might follow the footsteps of Bear Stearns, Wachovia, Merrill Lynch & Lehman Brothers? Will it be swallowed whole by a rival, like JPMorgan Chase or will it go belly up and disappear. The mightly financials and the mighty companies are falling; GE is begging for mercy and GM finally admitted today that it is not a viable enterprise without bailout funds.

The very lives of these companies that have ruled the world for as long as I've known are collapsing. These mighty companies were the kings of the jungle, conjuring strength, agility and invincibility. Maybe if the Bellwethers like GE are cracking, this is a signal of the passing of an old era. Maybe these companies are not supposed to survive at all. Maybe these are all unsustainable business models.

The government is trying to address the financial meltdown by injecting all of those bailout funds into the system. But maybe the financial system as we know it is no longer viable, maybe we are trying to fix something that is already broken.

Wednesday, March 4, 2009

A Populace Needs to be Educated

If I had one wish, it would be to time the bottom of the market. I would find some money and put it in and ride the next wave to financial glory. Of course, it is a wish, for as we have been told through our formative years, there is no way to time the market. Nevertheless, we have pundits, daily, trying to call the bottom. It seems that we are already so sick of the financial pain that we need to wrap it up and get to the next level. Sorry lads and lasses, no generation gets away with everything.

We would not be well-rounded citizens if we did not feel the pain and make no mistake about it, there is plenty more pain to come. Me, I am just calling for a showing of the hands, someone, anyone, brave-up and tell the truth and let us know how much you really need AIG? GMAC? and the rest of you clowns hiding from a real valuation of those so-called toxic assets. AIG, what would it really cost to cover those bets? GE Money/GE Capital, Citigroup, Merrill Lynch/Bank of America, how much of those bets did you make? The best thing that the government can do now is to order all of these financials hiding behind their faux balance sheets to tell us the real deal.

If Obama is to be praised for a "true up" of the 2010 budget as he strives to incorporate all government expenses - all off-the-books expenditures like the costs for war and the deficiencies in the AMT and other budget machinations, i.e. no bid contracts and the like, why are we not demanding this from the companies who we are bailing out? Where are the forensic accountants when you need them? At this point in this dismal economic cycle, we need to know how much of these off-the-books assets are out there. Today, I am hearing that Bernanke wants to inject a trillion dollars into the shadow banking system, the system where all of these off-the-books assets reside like those credit swap derivatives.

We sit around and complain that there is no transparency in the system but we are not demanding answers. We need an independent citizens brigade to track all of these taxpayer dollars that are being injected into the financial system. At the very least, the taxpayer should know how much and to whom all of this money is being given. We should be protesting over this but our own financial woes are crippling us. Who has time to check out who the government is giving money to when our own personal financial lives are in shambles? I have been out of work 3 months; this milestone is now resonating on a daily basis. The reality has set in that the return on resume submission is dismal, there has been only one interview for nearly 50 submitted. These are not the type of odds that step up the employment quotient though I am hearing that I am lucky to have had one callback.

The bigger question is why I have not been able to get to the bottom of this financial crisis in all of its complexity. Previous recessions were explainable but this most recent debacle is rooted in financial instruments that we, the taxpayer, simply do not understand. There needs to be a whole-hearted effort on the part of the media and the government to explain the elements and educate a society on its new role as financial savior. Now we have people taking sides, even myself, trying to simplify the matter, saying bloviated statements like "let them fail," "no more bailouts," and "the democrats are mortgaging the future" and so on. What is the truth? I am being led to believe that while the government is supposedly bailing out AIG, GE, GM, and the rest of those fat-cats under some dubious rubric of "too big to fail," they are not explaining the real reason; the devasting financial shock to the worldwide banking/financial system of valuing all of those derivatives.

If this is true, then it needs to be explained to the American people. We have nothing to lose and everything to gain. We do not want the financial equivalent of the post 9-11 exhortation of "go out and shop, carry on as you normally do" response to crisis, we should be demanding a real appraisal of what we are getting into with these continued bailouts. If the situation is dire, tell us. Last fall, businesses were planning on a turnaround during the second half of this year. We have now reached the reality stage where it is clear that the turnaround may not happen until 2010 or beyond. I might have planned better last Fall if I had known that. Facts need to be faced. A populace needs to be educated.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Obamanomics

Welcome to Obanomics. Will the massive expenditure of Government capital hold back the tides of disaster about to wash up on our shores? What will be the collateral damage because there will be some? How does one come to terms with the impending higher taxes looming in the near distant future that will be required to quell the massive deficit beast that has been unleashed?

The questions keep mounting. The Republicans have some salient points but they sound like the boy crying wolf because they still want to keep blaming instead of recognizing that they contributed greatly to our common woe by not sticking to their core principles of fiscal responsibility: small government and lower taxes. After presiding over the largest government expansion, costly wars and record-breaking deficits that led to an almost tripling of the national debt, they are now screaming and complaining about Obamanomics.

I am not sure how the Republican party, now framed by Michael Steele, Rush Limbaugh, Sarah Palin and Bobby Jindal with their number one hate-mongering cheerleaders Sean Hannity, Michelle Bachmann and Ann Coulter, can expect any rational minded person to take note of their platform. Even CPAC's best polling efforts turned up Mitt Romney with 20% of the vote as most likely to be the best Republican contender in 2012. Ron Paul turned up at 13% tied with Sarah Palin. I think the Republicans should turn to Ron Paul for an alternate plan to Obama and the tired tax-reductions-will-spur-growth economics begun by Reagan and bastardized by Bush then maybe they will have a chance. Even I liked Ron Paul.

I am rooting for Obamanomics. I am legitimately concerned about the expense but I'm hoping that it does work down the road to stem the tide of joblessness and wealth eradication. Tomorrow I have a job interview for a part-time job against a tide of abyssmal data of escalating layoffs, jobless claims and under-employment. The last time I got a job, it was lost to layoff within 3 months. It would be nice to get a job but I am well aware of the future uncertainties that threaten its tenure. Remember those people who showed up for their first day of work at American Home Mortgage just to find out that the company had collapsed that same day?

Thankfully, the Presidential race took up most of 2008 so we shielded from much of the bad news of 2008. Now that the President has been inaugurated, we have nothing to distract us from the near deafening drumroll of bad economic data and a tumbling stock market down 50% from its high in October 2007.

It probably would not have been so bad if we weren't all in so much debt, from the government on down to the little man. It is the debt that is doing us in. All of the financial instruments bought and created by this debt are collapsing. When so many corporations are borrowing from Peter (the Government) to pay Paul (their creditors) and Peter (the Government) is borrowing from foreign governments and institutions to pay Paul (every single penny of every single bailout package so far), we've taken that simple homily up to a whole new level.

It seems there is always this call for more expansion and that expansion cannot happen without leverage yet every time expansion is based on leverage it collapses and we still have to wait a significant number of years to get back to where we were because in reality it was going to take a significant number of years for a certain percentage of growth to materialize. Speeding up that growth to occur in a few odd years or so gives us momentary satisfaction because we still have to spend the remaining years wallowing with no growth and/or fighting for some sense of growth until the normal passage of years is satisfied. How long was it going to take for us to grow from 1997 on? Certainly it was not 10 years. So now we have to wait to find out where we are on the growth curve. Apparently we were way ahead of where we were supposed to be. How long was it supposed to take for that growth to materialize?

Only real dollars can spur growth. A company takes their profits and puts them back into the business until they reach a desirable rate of return. So far, history has shown us that we can't get ahead of ourselves. If we settled for tiny but steady increases then we would probably not have these massive corrections. In the end, it all has to correct. One could argue that the government has bought into this economic logic of borrowing to spur growth when in actuality there should be no growth. We took it all and enjoyed it all already. The faster we use up the spoils that are not of our labors the longer we have to do without. How many years is it going to be this time around?

Maybe we really don't need Obamanomics at all. Maybe we just need to tread water, put the next phase in place, and wait until we land back on the growth curve of where we were supposed to be in the first place. Maybe this is what Obamanomics should be.


Monday, March 2, 2009

Reflections on a Dow: Revisited

The Dow broke the sixes today, down 300 points to close at 6763 points. As I said last week, it was not impossible and here we are already. Now we are back to 1997 levels, we are now past Bush and back in Clinton! Reality Check. I thought I would look into the Dow a little further to try to understand some of the history. I have run some of these numbers in a previous post but I refer to them more in detail today as I again try to understand the specs and put the whole stock market thing into some historical context. What does all of this numbers posturing mean as I watch the Index begin to majorly tank again?

At the beginning of the last century, the Dow was around 50 points. From 1901-1990 it increased 2950 points winding up around 3000 at the beginning of the 1990s. It has spectacularly increased since 1990. From 1990-2007, the Dow increased over 10,000 points even after dropping down to 7600 points in the Fall of 2002 when the Tech Bubble finally burst for good. This is a significant statistic: 90 years to increase 2950 points, 17 years to increase 10,000 points.
The last 17 years have been all the more artificial because of all the available cheap capital.

We racked up incredible wealth in a small number of years if we look back at stock market history. Even the WWII boom increased the market from around 140 points in 1944 to the 700s in the early 1960s. For all of the conversation about the Great Depression, the DJIA was at a high of 381 points when the market crashed in 1929 when it slid down to slightly less than 200 points. Despite numerous efforts to power a reversal, the index finally hit a low of 41 points in mid 1932. After that it had its moments regularly peaking and troughing between 1960 and 1980 reaching a low of 535 points and a high of 1051 points during that 20 year period.

The DJIA began in earnest to steadily ratchet up under Reagan and added approximately 2000 points between 1981 and 1991. The major dip during that period was black Mondayin October 1987 when the market plunged nearly 1000 points from a highpoint of 2722 points. It gained over 8000 points between 1991 and 2001 rising from 2500 in 1991 to the 6700s in 1997 - where we are now - and upward to just shy of 11,500 at the end of 1999 gaining 9000 points under Clinton and a pronounced gain between 1997 and 1999 thanks to the tech boom which corrected itself in 2002 landing the market at 7600 points. This was shortlived and the market nearly doubled adding another 6400 points in 5 years to a high of 13930 in Oct 2007.
It has fallen ever since and here we are now.

So the swings that we are becoming "used to" these days of several hundred points up or down and into almost 1000 point peak to trough swings in one day cannot possibly be true commerce and therefore is no longer any indicator of where the market should or should not be. Unless you are one of the lucky to have had enough money to weather the current downturn or you have a good union type job with a pension, all of the wealth created since the turn of this new century has been wiped out completely
putting the Dow back to 1990s levels.

By that reckoning, we have much more to bleed to bring business and building back to those levels. The problem is that you cannot do it without leaving too many relics i.e. abandoned big box store shopping centers. Most of us in the middle class just woke to the fact that we never had any real money to spend; we simply did not realize how hard it would be to pay back all of that debt; rolling into the mortgage and feeling no pain was just the luck of the draw and you did it if you could. Besides, wasn't it good for America?

We really didn't earn anything. We simply spent money that we didn't really have - debt - and now we have to pay some of that down before we can go on. I am trying to remember the last time I was better off...ah yes, the 1990s was it for me.